How Mimar Sinan’s Works Brought Ottoman Architecture to Its Peak

Mimar Sinan’s works span hundreds of buildings, from mosques to waterways. According to the TDV Encyclopedia of Islam, a comparison of the sources yields a list of 452 buildings, while some handbooks put the figure at around 350. Mimar Sinan described the stages of his career through the Şehzade, Süleymaniye and Selimiye mosques. The Selimiye is cited as his greatest work. So how did these buildings carry the Ottoman art of building to its peak?

Quick Summary

  • The number of Mimar Sinan’s works is disputed: a comparison of the sources gives 452, some handbooks around 350.
  • Sinan called the Şehzade Mosque “my apprentice work” and the Süleymaniye “my journeyman work”.
  • The Selimiye is regarded as his greatest work; his largest work by volume, however, is the Kırkçeşme water system.
  • His works range from mosques and madrasas to baths, bridges and aqueducts.
  • Atik Sinan, by contrast, was a different master who lived in the reign of Mehmed the Conqueror and completed the Fatih Mosque.

Contents

Mimar Sinan’s Works: How Many Are There?

The fullest information on Sinan’s life is found in the Tezkiretü’l-bünyân (“Record of Buildings”), written by his friend, the poet Sai Mustafa Çelebi. According to Selçuk Mülayim, this memoir, thought to have been written in 1586–1587, was compiled from Sinan’s own accounts. Sai’s other work, the Tezkiretü’l-ebniye (“Record of Edifices”), lists the names of the buildings by type in thirteen sections.

Representational painting evoking Mimar Sinan's works: an elderly master studying large plans on a balcony overlooking a domed mosque

Mülayim points out that the building lists in the two memoirs do not match each other, although they partly complement each other. For this reason the total number of Mimar Sinan’s works is disputed. When the sources of the period are compared, a list of 452 buildings emerges. Some handbooks and encyclopedias, on the other hand, count around 350 works. The Sinan entry does not give the number of buildings counted by each memoir separately.

For Mimar Sinan’s works in Istanbul there is also a more detailed inventory. The encyclopedia’s Istanbul entry writes that the building activity between 1540 and 1588 could be called “the Sinan era”. In this period Sinan and his team built forty-three mosques, fifty-two mescids (small mosques) and forty-nine madrasas in the city. The same inventory also includes twenty-eight palaces and pavilions, forty baths, six hans (inns), seven darülkurras (schools of Quran recitation), three imarets (public kitchens) and three hospitals.

The master cannot be expected to have stood over each of Mimar Sinan’s works in person. Mülayim draws attention to the vastness of the country, where travel was on horseback. In his view, it is conceivable that Sinan only drew the plans of some buildings and supervised their construction through his assistants. The Süleymaniye Complex in Damascus is an example: according to Baha Tanman, at the end of 1553 Muslihuddin Halife of the Corps of Imperial Architects (Hassa) was sent there on Sinan’s direction, while Todoros of Damascus was in charge of the construction.

Apprentice, Journeyman, Master: Which Is His Greatest Work?

Sinan defined his progress in the profession through three great mosques. According to the Sinan entry, he called the Şehzade Mosque “my apprentice work” and the Süleymaniye “my journeyman work”. The Süleymaniye entry regards this remark as an expression of the master’s stage of professional development and of his constant enthusiasm for progress.

The third building is the Selimiye in Edirne. The Sinan entry quotes no words of his about this mosque; it only cites it as his greatest work. The fact that the Selimiye is widely called his masterwork continues this sequence; the encyclopedia does not present this description as Sinan’s own words. Step by step, the three mosques show how the quest for the dome matured within Mimar Sinan’s works.

Şehzade Mosque (1548): The Apprentice Work

Suleiman the Magnificent wanted to build a complex in the name of his son, Prince Mehmed, who had died in 1543. According to the Sinan entry, the work was given to Sinan, who was then fifty-four years old. İsmail Orman writes that this was the first selatin (imperial) complex designed by Sinan. The foundations of the mosque were laid on 23 May 1544, and the mosque opened for worship in August 1548.

In the plan, four semi-domes support the central dome. According to Orman, Sinan applied his own distinctive pyramidal roofing system here for the first time. Because he concealed the buttresses inside arcaded galleries, he was able to open up the walls with numerous windows. In this way, the first seeds of the conception of the dome that would reach perfection in the Selimiye appeared. Orman, for his part, regards the lively relief decoration on the façades as experiments of Sinan’s “apprenticeship period”.

Süleymaniye (1550–1557): The Journeyman Work

A few years after the Şehzade was completed, work began on a new complex in the name of the sultan. According to Mülayim, the sources give 1550 as the year the foundations were laid; although the month and day are disputed, 13 June 1550 can be accepted. Sinan relates that at the opening, held on Friday, 15 October 1557, he presented the key to the sultan. The sultan, however, handed the key back and left him the honor of opening the mosque.

The complex was set on the most suitable spot of a ridge sloping toward the Golden Horn, on part of the grounds of the Old Palace. According to Mülayim, with this choice Sinan showed himself to be an urban planner who made the most efficient use of the topography. The main dome is 27.40 meters in diameter, and its height is slightly over 50 meters. Sixty-four jars set into the shell of the dome ensure that sound is distributed evenly.

Selimiye (Edirne): The Greatest Work

Sinan was eighty-three years old when he completed this mosque, which he built in Edirne for Selim II. According to the Sinan entry, because of his old age he was by then known by the epithet “Koca” (“the Elder”). According to the Selimiye entry, the mosque, the madrasas and the eastern shops of the arasta (market street) were built in 1568–1574. The encyclopedia’s Mosque (Cami) entry, however, gives the years of construction as 1569–1575. It is accepted that the western wing of the arasta and the primary school were completed by Davud Ağa in the reign of Murad III.

The mosque rises in the center of the city, on Kavak Square in the area of the old palace. Those approaching Edirne begin to see its minarets from 10–15 kilometers away. The dome rests on eight piers; the Selimiye entry gives its diameter as 31.30 meters, the Mosque entry as 31.5 meters. According to Mülayim and Çobanoğlu, in the unity of its interior space the Selimiye surpassed Hagia Sophia and all the sultans’ mosques.

Representational painting of a mosque interior showing a lofty dome, the row of windows in its drum and arched windows

The minarets, too, establish a new order. The four minarets, each with three balconies (şerefe), are 70.89 meters high. According to the Selimiye entry, this is the first time that minarets rise from the corners of the enclosed space covered by the dome. Dayezade Mustafa Efendi, who lived in the 18th century, also writes that Sinan made a “mücessem tersîm” (a three-dimensional rendering) of this mosque and presented it to the sultan. According to Mülayim, records of this kind prove that perspective drawings and even scale models were prepared.

Mimar Sinan’s Works by Period (1538–1588)

The Ottomans (Osmanlılar) entry regards this period as the peak era of the art of building. The main undertakings of the era were urban buildings, water works and the menzil külliyes (way-station complexes) along the roads of Rumelia and the pilgrimage routes. Following Mimar Sinan’s works reign by reign makes this development easier to see.

Mimar Sinan’s Works of the First Decade

The Haseki Complex was Sinan’s first work after he took office. According to Sema Doğan, the mosque of the complex, built in the name of Hürrem Sultan, was erected in 1538–1539 with a single dome. Cahit Baltacı, too, regards this complex as the greatest charitable work commissioned by Hürrem Sultan.

The Mihrimah Sultan Complex in Üsküdar was completed in 1547, according to the inscription of its mosque. According to Orman, Sinan built this complex at the same time as the Şehzade. Its panoramic setting along the shore showed early in his career that he was a good urban planner. The Şehzade Mosque was completed in 1548 and became Sinan’s first great sultan’s mosque.

Suleiman the Magnificent’s Last Years (1550–1566)

These were the years of the Süleymaniye and of the great waterways. Work on the Kırkçeşme water system began in 1554, and the system was finished before 1563. The Rüstem Pasha Complex, for its part, rose between 1555 and 1561 in a busy commercial district. The mosque is fevkani (raised), that is, it sits on top of the storerooms and shops beneath it. According to Tokay, its walls are covered with the finest İznik tiles of the period.

The Reigns of Selim II and Murad III (1566–1588)

The Büyükçekmece Bridge, begun in the reign of Suleiman the Magnificent, was completed under Selim II in 1567–1568. According to the Selim II entry, the sultan had Hagia Sophia reinforced with buttresses and entrusted this repair to Sinan. The six-gated Ali Pasha Bazaar in Edirne also dates from 1569. The Sokullu Mehmed Pasha Complex in Lüleburgaz was finished in 1569 or, at the latest, in the early 1570s.

In the reign of Murad III, Sinan built the mosque at Azapkapı for Sokullu; its inscription is dated 1577–1578. According to Semavi Eyice, Sinan applied the system of the Selimiye here on a smaller scale. The Kılıç Ali Pasha Mosque in Tophane was completed in 1580 and became one of his last great works. Eyice regards this mosque not as a simple imitation of Hagia Sophia but as a structurally safer stage of it.

The Atik Valide Mosque of Nurbanu Valide Sultan in Üsküdar was built in its original form between 1570 and 1579. Baha Tanman reminds us that by the 1580s Sinan had grown very old and assigned some building projects to his assistants. For this reason, the share of the assistants must be taken into account in Mimar Sinan’s works of the final years. When Sinan set out on the pilgrimage in 1584, he left Mehmed Subaşı as his deputy. Although he was nearing a hundred on his return, he continued in office and died in 1588.

In Which Fields Was Mimar Sinan Strongest? His Works by Type

Mimar Sinan’s works are not confined to a single building type. Mülayim sees Sinan as the most renowned figure in urban planning, in the management of operations and in the organization of building work. Even the Istanbul inventory lists many types of building, from mosques to hans. To these are added tombs, bridges, aqueducts, bazaars and the way-station complexes along the roads.

Waterways and Bridges

Kâzım Çeçen regards the Kırkçeşme water system as Sinan’s most important work of engineering. In his view, it is also his largest work by volume. Among Mimar Sinan’s works, this project cost even more than the Süleymaniye: the Süleymaniye cost 35 million akçe, Kırkçeşme 50 million. The grand vizier Rüstem Pasha opposed bringing the water into the city, arguing that the population would grow. Suleiman the Magnificent, however, ordered that the water be brought as his own waqf (pious endowment) and that the construction continue.

Uzunkemer, on the western branch, is the largest structure of the system at 711 meters long. The Moğlova Aqueduct is 47.11 meters high from its foundations, the equivalent of a sixteen-story building. According to Çeçen, Sinan was the first to build aqueduct walls and piers with a trapezoidal cross-section. In Sinan’s time, about 300 fountains were fed by Kırkçeşme.

The Büyükçekmece Bridge is 635.57 meters long and has twenty-eight arches. On the left edge of its inscription one reads the words “amel-i Yûsuf b. Abdullah” (“the work of Yusuf, son of Abdullah”). According to Eyice, this is the only known signature of Sinan on one of his works. His writing the name Yusuf instead of the name by which he was known may be seen as a sign of his wish to appear modest.

Baths, Bazaars and Way Stations: Mimar Sinan’s Works That Generated Income

Some buildings were built directly to produce income. The double Haseki Bath, built in front of Hagia Sophia for Hürrem Sultan, is one of Sinan’s important works. According to Eyice, a second Haseki bath, in Eminönü, also appears in the lists of his works. This bath, built according to its endowment deed (vakfiye) to provide income for Hürrem’s endowments, was demolished around 1930. The Ali Pasha Bazaar in Edirne, too, is an arasta founded to bring income to the endowments of Semiz Ali Pasha.

Menzil külliyesi (way-station complex) is the name given to complexes built on main routes such as Istanbul–Edirne or Istanbul–Hejaz. The Ottomans entry lists the Büyükçekmece, Babaeski, Lüleburgaz and Havsa complexes that Sinan built on the Istanbul–Edirne road. In Lüleburgaz, the arasta with fifty-nine shops on both sides of the road forms the backbone of the complex. According to the Mosque entry, Sinan also built way-station complexes at Karapınar in Konya for Sultan Selim and at Payas for Sokullu.

Külliye and Waqf: How Did His Works Change the City?

The largest of Mimar Sinan’s works are not single buildings but groups of buildings that lived on waqf endowments. At the Süleymaniye, the units are laid out in a “U” arrangement on a site of about sixty dönüms (a traditional unit of land area). They include madrasas teaching at four levels, a darülhadis (school of hadith), a medical madrasa, a şifahane (hospital), a darülkurra, a primary school, an imaret, a han and a bath. Evliya Çelebi writes that the complex was covered by “a thousand domes” and that 3,000 people served there.

According to the encyclopedia’s Istanbul entry, all the endowments of the Süleymaniye were combined in a single endowment deed. According to a tax survey (tahrir) from the reign of Murad III, the endowment’s revenues reached 5,277,759 akçe. Of this income, 81 percent came from the taxes of some 230 villages in Rumelia. The complex employed 748 staff, whose annual salaries came to 1 million akçe. We described how this system worked in general in our article on the Ottoman waqf system.

Construction, too, was the work of a large team. According to the same entry, of the 3,523 workers employed at the Süleymaniye, 51 percent were Christian and 49 percent Muslim. Of the workers, 55 percent were free wage earners, 40 percent were acemi oğlanları (novice recruits) and 5 percent were galley convicts. This picture shows that the works came not from the hands of a single master but from a large organization.

Representational painting of a mosque with its semi-domes and slender minarets and the city around it at sunset

In some complexes the source of income was part of the plan. The Selimiye arasta, which Evliya Çelebi called the Kavaflar Çarşısı (the Shoemakers’ Market), was built to provide income for the mosque. The arasta is 255 meters long and has 124 shops.

Among Mimar Sinan’s works there is also a mescid that he built at his own expense. Next to the mescid at Yenibahçe, in Fatih, stood a primary school (sıbyan mektebi) and a fountain. According to Sema Doğan, Sinan endowed houses, shops and 300,000 akçe for the mescid. In his endowment deed he stipulated that those who would hold his office after him should oversee the endowment.

Sinan lies in a corner of the Süleymaniye Complex, in a tomb resembling a garden arbor. The tombs of Suleiman the Magnificent and Hürrem Sultan are also in the complex. According to Mülayim, an arrangement that, alongside these, also houses the tomb of the master who built the complex has no parallel. The Istanbul entry writes that this tomb is generally likened to a signature. Its inscription ends with a line by his friend Sai: “Geçti bu demde cihandan pîr-i mi‘mârân Sinân” (“At this moment Sinan, the elder of architects, passed from the world”).

Why Was the Office of Chief Architect Important?

Sinan came to prominence with the bridge he built over the Prut River during the Moldavian campaign of 1538. According to the Sinan entry, the forty-eight-year-old master finished the bridge in thirteen days. He was then appointed to the post left vacant by the death of his predecessor, known as “Acem Alisi” (“Ali the Persian”). His signature and the border of his seal bear the phrase “sermi‘mârân-ı Hâssa” (“head of the imperial architects”). He remained “reîs-i mi‘mârân” (“chief of the architects”) until his death.

This office was the center of the state’s building works. According to the Ottomans entry, surveying, planning and construction were carried out by this office. The supply of materials, purchasing and payments, on the other hand, were the duty of the şehremini (the city intendant). The same entry likens this post to today’s ministry of public works, and sometimes to the office of mayor.

According to Şerafettin Turan, the corps under this office also built and repaired state and waqf buildings outside Istanbul. It therefore worked on an imperial scale. In Sinan’s time, when buildings put up by unqualified people soon collapsed or burned down, an order was issued. Under this order, the office was not to let unqualified people carry out building work. We discussed the founding and workings of the corps in our article on the characteristics of Ottoman art.

According to Mülayim, the spread of the classical style across a vast geography shows that a single center shaped it. According to the Ottomans entry, after Sinan the work was carried on by the masters he had trained. The first three names of this period are Davud Ağa, Dalgıç Ahmed Ağa and Sedefkar Mehmed Ağa. The same entry notes, however, that little innovation was seen in this period, and that there was even stagnation. You can read about the support the sultans gave to these buildings in our article on the sultans and the arts.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why Is the Selimiye Considered Mimar Sinan’s Greatest Work?

The Sinan entry names the Selimiye in Edirne as the master’s greatest work. According to the Selimiye entry, the mosque is the culmination of the quest for unity of space. In terms of volume, however, the Kırkçeşme entry states that his largest work is the Kırkçeşme water system.

Who Was Atik Sinan, and What Are His Works?

Atik Sinan, or Azadlı Sinan, lived before the Sinan of Suleiman the Magnificent’s reign and was the leading master of the age of Mehmed the Conqueror. His full name was Sinaneddin Yusuf bin Abdullah; according to his tombstone, he died on 13 September 1471. In 1470 he completed the Fatih Mosque and Complex, the first and largest building group in Istanbul. The mescid he had built in Fatih is known today as the Kumrulu Mescid, and his grave is also there. According to Zeki Sönmez, the story that Mehmed the Conqueror had his hands cut off is not true.

In Which Field Was Mimar Sinan Strongest?

Sinan’s greatest strength was the domed space. In the Selimiye, the wide central area is gathered undivided beneath the central dome. The Süleymaniye and Mihrimah Sultan complexes show that he was a good urban planner. Kırkçeşme, in turn, reveals his skill as an engineer.

Why Is Mimar Sinan Important?

Mülayim describes him as the only figure who carried the Ottoman art of building to the summit on a world scale. In his view, Sinan’s style put an end to the “anarchy of forms” in the provinces and cities where it took root. The masters he trained carried this style into the following century.

In Which Cities Are Mimar Sinan’s Works Found?

Istanbul is the city where they are most concentrated. According to the Edirne entry, Edirne’s finest buildings of the 16th century are also Sinan’s. The way-station complexes on the Istanbul–Edirne road and the buildings in Karapınar, Payas and Damascus are also counted among his works.

Conclusion

Over a fifty-year tenure, Mimar Sinan’s works took shape across a wide range, stretching from mosques to bridges. The quest for the dome that began at the Şehzade matured at the Süleymaniye and reached its peak at the Selimiye. Kırkçeşme and Büyükçekmece showed his side as an engineer. The külliyes, sustained by waqfs, placed these buildings at the center of urban life.

Sinan’s importance does not come from the number of his buildings alone. A style spreading from a single center made the classical period speak the same language across a vast geography. That is why Mimar Sinan’s works still tell the story of the peak of Ottoman architecture most clearly today.

Sources

Leave a Comment