What Was the Tanzimat Edict? The Beginning of Change in the Ottoman Empire

The Tanzimat Edict, officially the Edict of Gülhane (Gülhane Hatt-ı Hümâyunu), is the reform document read out in the Gülhane square on 3 November 1839. This edict of Sultan Abdülmecid was read by the Foreign Minister, Mustafa Reşid Pasha. It promised security of life, protection of property and honour, taxation according to each person’s means and military service of fixed length. These rights were granted to all subjects, Muslim and non-Muslim alike.

Representative painting of the Tanzimat Edict being proclaimed: statesmen holding documents under a palace portico and a crowd listening to them

Quick Summary

  • The Tanzimat Edict was read out on 3 November 1839 in the Gülhane square, before the dignitaries of the state and foreign envoys.
  • The sultan was the sixteen-year-old Abdülmecid; the text was read by Mustafa Reşid Pasha.
  • It promised security of life and property, fair taxation and military service of four or five years.
  • These rights were granted equally to all subjects, Muslim and non-Muslim.
  • In the background lay the defeat at Nizip, the Egyptian crisis and the need to win Europe’s support.
  • The reform era it opened ended, according to the general view, in 1878.

Contents

What Was the Tanzimat Edict?

The TDV Encyclopedia of Islam treats this document under the name Gülhane Hatt-ı Hümâyunu, the Edict of Gülhane. According to the encyclopedia, because the text launched the Tanzimat era, it is also known as the Tanzimat Edict. In short, the popular name comes from the period the edict opened. The official name, by contrast, indicates the type of document and the place where it was read.

What Is the Tanzimat, and What Does the Word Mean?

In the dictionary, the word tanzîm means “to arrange, to put in order, to reform”. Its plural, tanzîmât, is used in the literature to mean the reform and reorganization of the civil administration. The word also refers to the period in which these reforms were carried out. In 1838 Mahmud II had founded the Meclis-i Vala (Supreme Council of Judicial Ordinances). He gave it the task of discussing the reforms he called the “Tanzîmât-ı Hayriyye” (“the Auspicious Reforms”).

What Is the Difference Between a Ferman and a Hatt-ı Hümayun?

According to the TDV Encyclopedia of Islam, ferman is the general name for the sultan’s tughra-bearing orders written in line with decisions of the imperial council (divan). An order written in the sultan’s own hand, on the other hand, is called a hatt-ı hümayun. According to the encyclopedia, the Tanzimat Edict can be counted among the hatt-ı hümayuns of the adaletname type (rescripts of justice) that sultans proclaimed on coming to the throne. This text, however, brought innovations that would shake the traditional order to its foundations.

When and Where Was the Tanzimat Edict Proclaimed?

The edict was read out on 3 November 1839 in the Gülhane square by the Foreign Minister, Mustafa Reşid Pasha. The audience included the ministers, the high dignitaries of the state, the ulema, the Greek and Armenian patriarchs, the chief rabbi, representatives of the guilds and foreign envoys. Sultan Abdülmecid followed the ceremony from the Gülhane Pavilion.

After the reading, cannons were fired and sacrificial animals were slaughtered. In the Chamber of the Holy Mantle (Hırka-i Şerif Dairesi), the sultan swore to abide by the provisions of the edict. In his oath he said that he would pass no judgment for or against anyone unless it accorded with the laws. Nor would he allow the laws already made, or yet to be made, to be altered. According to the edict, the ministers, officials and ulema would also take an oath, and those who did not comply would be punished regardless of rank.

The reformers even considered erecting a monument on the spot where the edict had been read. But because the site lay within the palace grounds, it would have been hard for the public to visit, so the idea was dropped. The idea of erecting the monument in Beyazıt Square was not realized either.

In Which Sultan’s Reign Was the Tanzimat Edict Proclaimed?

The Tanzimat Edict was proclaimed in the reign of Sultan Abdülmecid. Abdülmecid had come to the throne at the age of sixteen on 1 July 1839, on the death of his father, Mahmud II. The document was therefore read about four months after the young sultan’s accession.

Why Was the Tanzimat Edict Proclaimed?

Internal and external causes were intertwined in the proclamation of the edict. In the summer of 1839 the state was in a deep crisis. At the centre of this crisis lay the Egyptian question.

Internal Causes: The Egyptian Crisis and the Accumulated Reforms

The Egyptian question, caused by Muhammad Ali Pasha of Kavala, had been occupying the state for about eight years. The costs of the army fighting the rebellion had strained the treasury. On 24 June 1839 the Egyptian forces inflicted a heavy defeat on the Ottoman army at Nizip. On 3 July 1839, moreover, Grand Admiral (kaptan-ı derya) Ahmed Fevzi Pasha took the fleet to Egypt and handed it over to Muhammad Ali Pasha. Thus, as the Abdülmecid entry puts it, the state was left without an army and without a navy.

The ground for the edict, however, had been prepared in the reign of Mahmud II. The sultan, who abolished the Janissary Corps in 1826, reorganized the central administration from top to bottom from the early 1830s onwards. He set up ministries (nezaret) and councils such as the Meclis-i Vala, and took steps towards abolishing the practice of confiscation (müsadere). We described the beginning of this transformation in our article on why the Janissary Corps was abolished.

Mahmud II saw winning the whole population over to the state, regardless of religion, as a vital necessity. According to the TDV Encyclopedia of Islam, what worried him even more was the warm welcome the Muslim population of Anatolia gave to the advance of the Egyptian forces. The Greek and Serbian revolts, for their part, had shown the danger of non-Muslims breaking away from the empire. According to the encyclopedia, the principle of equality in the edict was the first step of a project that aimed to create an Ottoman nation.

External Causes: Winning Europe’s Support

After Nizip, Britain, France, Russia, Austria and Prussia presented a joint note. The note, dated 27 July 1839, demanded that the Egyptian question not be settled without consulting them. According to the Abdülmecid entry, with the acceptance of this note the Ottoman state in a sense came under the tutelage of the European states. According to the same entry, Mustafa Reşid Pasha persuaded the young sultan to adopt a reform programme that would please the Europeans, so as to obtain Europe’s help.

According to the Abdülmecid entry, the favourable climate created by the edict also made it easier to settle the Egyptian question. Under the Treaty of London of 15 July 1840, the governorship of Egypt was left to Muhammad Ali Pasha on a hereditary basis. In return, the lands the pasha had occupied and the Ottoman fleet were recovered.

Representative painting of the preparation of the edict: in front of a domed building, uniformed statesmen and turbaned scholars gathered over documents on a table

Who Prepared the Tanzimat Edict?

On this question the entries of the TDV Encyclopedia of Islam place their emphasis differently. The Abdülmecid entry, written by Cevdet Küçük, states that Mustafa Reşid Pasha prepared the Edict of Gülhane himself. Ali Akyıldız, however, in the entry describing the period, does not find it convincing to attribute such a transformation to the initiative of a single bureaucrat. In his view, such a step could only have been taken with a serious consensus among the palace, the ulema and the bureaucracy.

As evidence, Akyıldız points to the accession rescript (cülus hatt-ı hümayunu) that Abdülmecid issued on 17 July 1839. This text already contained principles such as obedience to the law, the avoidance of bribery and the security of everyone’s life and property. Reşid Pasha, on the other hand, returned from London about a month and a half after this. Before the proclamation, a consultative assembly (meşveret meclisi) met under the chairmanship of Grand Vizier Koca Hüsrev Pasha. Thirty-eight senior bureaucrats and members of the religious establishment (ilmiye) took part in it. The principles adopted in the assembly were almost the same as those in the edict.

Half of those whose seals appear at the foot of the assembly’s report (mazbata) were members of the ulema. For this reason Akyıldız regards the edict as a product of the Ottoman state’s internal dynamics rather than of outside influences. The Mustafa Reşid Pasha entry, written by Kemal Beydilli, brings the two emphases together. Beydilli accepts that the pasha shared the responsibility with thirty-eight statesmen, but stresses that this does not diminish his active role in the proclamation.

What Were the Provisions of the Tanzimat Edict?

The Tanzimat Edict does not consist of numbered articles like modern laws. The text opens with a diagnosis: since its foundation the state had been strong because it followed the precepts of the Qur’an and the Sharia. But because these had not been observed for 150 years, weakness and poverty had set in. According to the edict, if the necessary measures were taken, the state could regain its former condition within five or ten years.

According to the summary in the TDV Encyclopedia of Islam, the main promises are the following:

  1. Security of life: No one would be sentenced to death without trial.
  2. Protection of property, honour and good name: Everyone would be free to dispose of their property and possessions as they wished.
  3. Fair taxation: Taxes would be levied according to each person’s means, and no one would be asked for more. It was indicated that the system of tax farming (iltizam), which harmed the people and the treasury, would be abolished.
  4. Regular military service: Recruitment would follow a set ratio, and the term of service would be four or five years. The edict stated that haphazard military service of indefinite length was undermining agriculture, trade and population growth.
  5. Equality: All subjects, Muslim and non-Muslim, would enjoy these rights in the same way.
  6. Meclis-i Vala: The number of the council’s members would be increased, and ministers and dignitaries would also attend its meetings from time to time.
  7. Military arrangements: These matters would be discussed and decided in the Dar-ı Şura-yı Askeri (Military Council).
  8. Fight against bribery: An effective law would be prepared to prevent bribery, which was causing the ruin of the country.
  9. Announcement: The edict would be proclaimed to the whole of public opinion at home and abroad.

According to the Abdülmecid entry, the document did not contain the principle of national sovereignty. Even so, it promised laws that would regulate relations between the state and the individual. The edict also aimed to put an end to arbitrary rule.

How Was the Tanzimat Edict Implemented?

Copies of the Tanzimat Edict were sent to the provincial governors, and the text was announced to the whole country through the official gazette Takvim-i Vekayi. The governors were asked to gather the leading people in public squares, read the edict to them and explain it “güzelce”, that is, clearly and well. The provisions other than those on taxation and military service were to be put into effect at once. The government feared that the edict might be misinterpreted and lead to revolts.

Indeed, each group interpreted the edict from its own point of view. Muslims disliked the new rights given to non-Muslims, while non-Muslims formed great expectations. Those whose interests were harmed, among them the ulema, the ayan (provincial notables) and even governors, stirred up the people, claiming that the Sharia was being violated. For this reason the reforms were first applied in places close to the centre, such as Edirne, Bursa, İzmir, Ankara, Aydın, Konya and Sivas. In Trabzon, by contrast, implementation was postponed because of the reactions.

According to Kemal Beydilli, a significant part of the statesmen saw the reforms as a way out of the Egyptian predicament. This was the reason for the insincerity with which the reforms were adopted and for the instability in their implementation. The conservative faction led by Koca Hüsrev Pasha was also a major obstacle for Reşid Pasha.

Why Was the Tax Reform Reversed?

One of the edict’s most important aims was the abolition of tax farming. The task of collecting taxes was given to muhassıls (tax collectors) sent from the centre with broad powers. In the sanjak centres, muhassıllık councils were set up in which the Muslim and non-Muslim population was represented. But treasury revenues fell, and in January 1840 the first paper money, bearing 12.5 per cent interest, was issued to cover the deficit.

The new system met with resistance from governors, local notables (eşraf and ayan), moneychangers (sarraf) and tax farmers (mültezim). These groups stood to pay more tax and to lose their exemptions. In April 1841 the Bulgarians launched a serious revolt in Niş, and in Tokat a muhassıl was killed. When the shortage of qualified officials was added to this, the system was abolished at the beginning of 1842 and tax farming was restored. According to the encyclopedia, the financial reforms of the period did not succeed.

What Changed in Military Service and Law?

For three years nothing could be done about the promises concerning military service. On 6 September 1843 it was decided that those to be conscripted would be chosen by lot. From March 1844, active service was limited to five years and reserve (redif) service to seven. In addition, five armies were formed under the names Hassa (Guard), Dersaadet (Istanbul), Rumeli, Anadolu and Arabistan.

In the field of law, the leading institution was the Meclis-i Vala, whose membership and powers were increased. The council, which also functioned as a high court, tried and punished even senior bureaucrats such as Hüsrev Pasha who acted against the reforms. On 3 May 1840 a penal code of forty-one articles was published. With an imperial decree (irade) dated 23 April 1847 and the Land Title Regulation (Tapu Nizamnamesi) that followed it, daughters and sons were given equal shares of their fathers’ inheritance.

Representative courtroom scene evoking the judicial order of the Tanzimat era: a judge at the bench, large scales of justice and people in different dress

The Consequences of the Tanzimat Edict

The Tanzimat Edict brought the idea of written guarantees and of law to the centre of Ottoman government. A penal code followed in 1840, a commercial code in 1850 and a land code in 1858. In education, the first rüşdiye (secondary school) was opened in 1847, and the first rüşdiye for girls in 1858. However, the coexistence of the new schools with the existing religious institutions gave rise to a dual structure in education and in law.

According to the Abdülmecid entry, the sultan tried to unite the various elements within the principle of equality and around the idea of Ottomanism. But the nationalism awakening among non-Muslims and the protection of the Western states made this unity impossible. We discussed Ottomanism and the currents that followed it in our article on Ottoman intellectual movements.

The Road to the Reform Edict

The European states considered the collection of the jizya from non-Muslims to be contrary to the principle of equality proclaimed by the Tanzimat Edict. On 18 February 1856, before the Congress of Paris, the Reform Edict (Islahat Fermanı) was proclaimed. The new edict confirmed the rights granted to the subjects in 1839 and gave non-Muslims extensive rights. According to Akyıldız, the Edict of Gülhane aimed to improve the condition of all subjects, whereas the Reform Edict aimed above all to improve that of non-Muslims.

Foreign Intervention and Criticism

In Europe, British and French public opinion welcomed the edict, while Austria and Russia received it unfavourably. Austria’s chief minister, Prince Metternich, criticized the reforms, fearing that similar demands would arise in his own country. Russia, for its part, was worried about the growing influence of Britain and France over the Ottoman state.

The envoys of the Great Powers also constantly interfered in internal affairs. Akyıldız attributes a significant part of the responsibility for this to Abdülmecid, who met frequently with the British ambassador Stratford Canning, and to Reşid Pasha, who had Britain’s backing. From 1865 onwards, the intellectuals known as the New Ottomans (Young Ottomans) criticized the Europe-centred foreign policy of Âli and Fuad Pashas. According to the encyclopedia, they found the two pashas too modernist and authoritarian. We described this opposition in our article on who the Young Ottomans were.

Which Years Did the Tanzimat Era Cover in the Ottoman Empire?

The period begins with the proclamation of 3 November 1839. Recent research, however, shows that the first measures of the period can be traced back to 1830. Its end date is disputed. The dates proposed also include 1871, when Âli Pasha died, and 1877, when Midhat Pasha was sent into exile. Another proposed date is 1881, when the Ottoman Public Debt Administration (Düyûn-ı Umûmiyye) was set up.

According to the TDV Encyclopedia of Islam, the general view is that the period ended in 1878 with the closure of the Chamber of Deputies (Meclis-i Mebusan). In the course of this process, the Kanun-ı Esasi (the Ottoman constitution) had come into force on 23 December 1876. But Abdülhamid II, relying on the authority granted by the Kanun-ı Esasi, prorogued the parliament indefinitely on 13 February 1878. You can read about the role of the sultans in this long age of reform in our article on Ottoman sultans and reform movements.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who Read the 1839 Tanzimat Edict?

The edict was read on 3 November 1839 by the Foreign Minister, Mustafa Reşid Pasha. Sultan Abdülmecid followed the ceremony from the Gülhane Pavilion.

Was the Tanzimat Edict a Constitution?

No. The edict contains guarantees given by the sultan and does not include the principle of national sovereignty. The Kanun-ı Esasi, which had the character of a constitution, came into force only on 23 December 1876.

What Is the Difference Between the Tanzimat Edict and the Reform Edict?

According to the encyclopedia, the 1839 edict aimed to improve the condition of all subjects. The Reform Edict of 1856, by contrast, introduced rights directed above all at non-Muslims.

Conclusion

The Tanzimat Edict, that is, the Edict of Gülhane, was proclaimed on 3 November 1839 in the shadow of the Egyptian crisis and the defeat at Nizip. It promised security of life and property, fair taxation, regular military service and equality regardless of religion. In practice the tax reform was reversed, and reactions and foreign interventions slowed the process. Even so, the Tanzimat Edict placed the idea of law-based guarantees and of a common body of subjects permanently on the Ottoman agenda.

Sources

4 thoughts on “What Was the Tanzimat Edict? The Beginning of Change in the Ottoman Empire”

Leave a Comment