Ottoman Coffee Culture: Why Were Coffeehouses Banned?

The story of Ottoman coffee begins toward the middle of the 16th century, when coffee reached Istanbul from Yemen by way of Egypt; the city’s first coffeehouses opened in the early 1550s. The coffeehouses were banned because the authorities regarded them as nests of disorder and of the gossip known as “devlet sohbeti” (“talk of state affairs”); some scholars also considered coffee a bid‘a, a reprehensible innovation. No single sultan imposed the bans; the harshest was Murad IV’s demolition of the coffeehouses in 1633.

Quick Summary

  • Coffee became known in Yemen in the early 15th century and, in the 16th century, reached Istanbul after Mecca and Cairo. Katib Çelebi writes that the coffee brought by ship in 1543 met with opposition because of fatwas prohibiting it.
  • Istanbul’s first coffeehouses opened in 1553 according to Mustafa Âli Efendi, and in AH 962 (1554–1555), in Tahtakale, according to Peçuylu İbrahim.
  • No single sultan banned coffee: closure orders were issued at the end of Suleiman the Magnificent’s reign and after it, and under Ahmed I grand viziers closed coffeehouses as well.
  • The harshest Ottoman coffee ban was the one Murad IV imposed after the Cibali fire of 1633; it was lifted in the early years of Mehmed IV’s reign.
  • The grounds were public order, the political gossip known as “devlet sohbeti” and moral concerns; the ulema issued differing fatwas on coffee.
  • The bans did not hold: the number of coffeehouses in Istanbul reached 1,631 in 1792 and 2,076 in 1821.

Contents

Ottoman coffee culture: an illustrative scene of men drinking coffee around a round table with brass ewers and cups, overlooking the sea and a mosque

Ottoman Coffee: Where Did It Come From, and When?

According to the Coffee (Kahve) entry of the TDV Encyclopedia of Islam, coffee was first used in Abyssinia, in the form of a food. It became known in Yemen in the early 15th century and spread as a beverage from the end of that century. It first found favor in Sufi circles, which stressed that coffee kept the body alert for worship and dhikr (the remembrance of God). In the early 16th century it passed to Mecca, and then to Cairo.

Exactly when Ottoman coffee drinking began is a matter of debate. Katib Çelebi writes that coffee arrived in Istanbul by ship in AH 950 (1543) but met with hostility because of fatwas prohibiting it. Al-Jaziri, the author of the earliest known work on coffee, likewise notes that during the pilgrimage season of the same year a piece of news spread in Mecca: the sultan had banned coffee in Istanbul. According to İdris Bostan, the author of the entry, these two records show that coffee had been consumed in Istanbul much earlier.

The Ottoman Coffee Route from Yemen to Istanbul

Coffee came to Istanbul mostly by sea and partly overland. Cargo leaving the ports of Yemen reached first Jeddah, then Suez and Egypt, and from there it was carried to Istanbul by ship. Even after the Ottoman army withdrew from Yemen in 1635, Ottoman merchants continued to sail to the Yemeni coast for coffee.

The First Coffeehouses in Istanbul

According to Ahmet Yaşar’s Coffeehouse (Kahvehane) entry, the spread of Ottoman coffee to the wider public and the growing number of coffeehouses were centered on Istanbul. By general consensus, the city’s first coffeehouses opened in the early 1550s. The contemporary historian Mustafa Âli Efendi writes that coffeehouses, long familiar in Arab lands, appeared in Istanbul in 1553.

According to the 17th-century historian Peçuylu İbrahim, the city’s first coffeehouses were opened in Tahtakale in AH 962 by Hakem, a merchant from Aleppo, and Şems from Damascus. The Gregorian equivalent of this year is given as 1555 in the Coffee entry and as 1554–1555 in the Coffeehouse entry.

Coffeehouses soon multiplied. According to the Coffeehouse entry, there were fifty coffeehouses in Istanbul in the last years of Suleiman the Magnificent. D’Ohsson, as cited in the Coffee entry, gives a figure of about 600 for the reigns of Selim II and Murad III, including small coffee stalls (kahve ocakları). According to Katib Çelebi, in the 17th century there was a coffeehouse at the head of almost every street in Istanbul.

How Did the Ulema Debate Coffee? Fatwas and the Kadızadelis

As coffee spread, its religious status also came under debate. According to the Coffee entry, there were two extreme views: one regarded coffee as almost part of worship, while the other held it to be haram (forbidden) as an intoxicating substance. Apart from these two extremes, most of the ulema considered coffee mubah (permissible). Some, however, declared it haram because of practices such as lying, backbiting and gambling in the places where it was drunk; in their view, too, coffee was permissible if such behavior was absent.

The Ottoman coffee debate was also approached from a medical angle. Mehmed Bedreddin Kosoni, chief physician to Suleiman the Magnificent, did not find coffee medically harmful; he said that, drunk in small amounts, it could have certain benefits. According to İdris Bostan, however, coffee was mostly deemed harmful for political reasons, and fatwas were issued against it. We discussed the place of the fatwa office in the state in our article on the şeyhülislam’s position between religion and state.

Ebussuud Efendi’s Position: Two Different Accounts

The view of the şeyhülislam (chief mufti) Ebussuud Efendi is reported differently in two entries of the encyclopedia. According to İdris Bostan’s Coffee entry, Ebussuud, judging by the state of the coffeehouses, issued fatwas against both coffee and the coffeehouses. He considered coffee haram because it was “the drink of the dissolute”. In his view, the “ehl-i hevâ” (people driven by their passions) played backgammon and chess in the coffeehouses, drank coffee after an intoxicating syrup and neglected their prayers; such places therefore had to be closed.

Ahmet Akgündüz’s Ebussuud Efendi entry, by contrast, writes that he issued a fatwa declaring coffee drinking permissible. Akgündüz counts this among the examples of how the şeyhülislam took social conditions and needs into account in his fatwas. According to the same entry, Ebussuud had also ruled that the shadow play was legitimate, on condition that it was watched “with an eye to drawing a lesson”.

Bostanzade’s Fatwa in Verse

According to the Coffee entry, the other important coffee fatwa of the 16th century belongs to Bostanzade Mehmed Efendi. The preacher İştipli Emir Efendi gathered all his objections to coffee into a question of twelve couplets. During his first term as şeyhülislam, Bostanzade replied with a poem of fifty-two couplets containing reasoned explanations. The fatwa is dated AH 1000 (1592); according to it, coffee does not intoxicate and is, moreover, good for one’s health. These benefits are set out in the fatwa under the heading “fevâid-i kahve” (“the benefits of coffee”).

The Kadızadelis and Coffee

According to the Coffeehouse entry, Bostanzade’s fatwa kept coffee, as a beverage, out of this debate. The bad reputation of the coffeehouses, on the other hand, was spread by the Kadızadeli movement. The movement takes its name from Kadızade Mehmed Efendi, one of the preachers of Murad IV’s reign. According to Semiramis Çavuşoğlu, Kadızade also regarded smoking tobacco and drinking coffee as bid‘a and haram.

Why Were Coffeehouses Banned?

The bans on Ottoman coffeehouses had no single cause; political, religious and moral motives were intertwined. According to Ahmet Yaşar, the coffeehouses, where the public gathered, attracted the attention of those in power and of officials. From the second half of the 16th century onward they were also regarded as the main venues of the upheavals that shook society from time to time.

“Devlet Sohbeti” and Concerns over Public Order

Coffeehouses were seen as places where the gossip and rumors known as “devlet sohbeti” spread. The political authorities considered them a threat to the established order and, in the early period, chose to close them down entirely. According to the Coffee entry, coffeehouses, which the ulema also frequented, were places of learned conversation; at times, however, they turned into venues where the people were incited during revolts. The entry links the occasional bans on opening coffeehouses in the 17th century to this situation as well.

Morality, the Tavern Comparison and Fire

The second motive was moral. According to the Coffee entry, the state regarded coffeehouses as a “fâsıklar mecmaı” (“gathering place of the dissolute”). Indeed, in 1568 the coffeehouses of Istanbul and Galata were banned, being treated in the same way as taverns. Accusations such as gaming, gambling and neglect of prayer also featured in the scholars’ objections. In the coffee ban of 1633, the danger of fire served as the pretext.

Which Sultan Banned Coffee? A History of the Ottoman Coffee Ban

There was no single sultan who banned coffee. Ottoman coffee and coffeehouse bans were issued under different sultans and took different forms. The harshest was Murad IV’s coffee ban of 1633, but none of them proved lasting.

Closure Orders from Suleiman the Magnificent to Ahmed I

According to the Coffee entry, orders recorded in the mühimme registers (the registers of imperial decrees) show that coffeehouses were closed in Homs in 1559 and in Aleppo, Damascus and Jerusalem in 1565. Two years later, the coffeehouses of Egypt, alleged to have become “dens of sedition”, and those around Eyüp were closed as well. In AH 975 (1568) it was the turn of Istanbul and Galata. The Coffeehouse entry, for its part, dates the closure orders in Istanbul to the last years of Suleiman the Magnificent’s reign.

These orders were sent to the qadis of Eyüp, Galata and Istanbul and demanded that the coffeehouses be closed and not reopened. According to Ahmet Yaşar, however, the ban did not last long, and new coffeehouses opened. A new order sent to the qadi of Istanbul in 1583 also failed to stop their spread. According to the Coffee entry, the grand viziers Derviş Pasha and Nasuh Pasha also closed coffeehouses in the reign of Ahmed I.

Murad IV’s Coffee Ban of 1633 and the Cibali Fire

According to the Coffee entry, the most violent reaction came from Murad IV. According to Ziya Yılmazer, the author of the Murad IV entry, the sultan had taken the government of the state entirely into his own hands in May 1632. We discussed the general crisis of the period in our article on how the Ottoman stagnation period began. According to Yılmazer, on 2 September 1633 a fire caused by a ship caulker outside the Cibali Gate (Cibalikapı) spread with the wind and reduced a fifth of the city to ashes.

The fire gave rise to much gossip, above all to loose talk in the coffeehouses. Kadızade Mehmed Efendi, who considered coffee and tobacco haram, thereupon urged the sultan on. On the pretext that a new fire might break out, Murad IV had the coffeehouses demolished and had rooms built in their place for bachelors, tanners and farriers. He also banned tobacco; he is known to have had the coffeehouses in Edirne demolished as well. Yılmazer notes that the sultan saw going along with the inclinations of zealous circles as an opportunity for his domestic policy.

Illustrative scene of a crowd gathered at night in front of a lantern-lit coffee shop, with a man in a red turban raising his hand as he speaks before the counter

İdris Bostan’s Coffee entry gives a different account of the cause of the fire. In this account, word spread that the fire had been started by people smoking tobacco in the coffeehouses. At Kadızade’s urging, a fatwa was obtained from the şeyhülislam Ahizade Hüseyin Efendi stating that coffee and tobacco were “bid‘at-ı seyyie” (“an evil innovation”). Then, by an imperial edict (ferman) dated 27 Safar 1043 (2 September 1633), the coffeehouses were closed in all Ottoman cities, Istanbul first among them. In Eyüp and its surroundings alone, 120 coffee shops were demolished.

The date of the fire is given as 2 September 1633 in the Murad IV and Coffee entries, and as August 1633 (Safar 1043) in the Kadızadeliler entry. According to Ahmet Yaşar, in 1633 Murad IV closed all the coffeehouses in Istanbul and also banned coffee drinking. According to the Kadızadeliler entry, the sultan also had many people who defied the tobacco ban put to death.

The severity of the coffee ban was interpreted in different ways. Naima, taking the conditions of the day into account, says that the sultan wanted to bring the ruffians and brigands to heel, and all but justifies the measure.

When Was the Coffee Ban Lifted?

According to the Coffee entry, the coffee ban was lifted in the early years of Mehmed IV’s reign. Solakzade and Katib Çelebi, who did not approve of so harsh a ban, welcomed its repeal. According to Ahmet Yaşar, the coffee ban of 1633 was the last decision to close the coffeehouses. From then on, the state looked for ways to keep coffeehouses under control and surveillance; closures were limited to places where improprieties were observed.

How Did Ottoman Coffeehouses Multiply Despite the Bans?

Ottoman coffee consumption kept growing despite the bans. According to the Coffee entry, in the 17th century coffee came to be offered to dignitaries of state at official meetings and to hold an important place in ceremonies. After that, consumption rose markedly and coffee became one of the necessities of daily life. The number of coffeehouses rose as well: according to registers drawn up in 1792 there were 1,631 coffeehouses in Istanbul, and in 1821 there were 2,076.

The Ottoman Coffee Trade, Taxes and Coffeehouse Revenues

The trade was large in volume. Every year 30,000–40,000 ferde (bales; 5,000 tons) of coffee came from Yemen to Egypt, and half of it was sent on to Istanbul and other Ottoman cities. Because coffee was little approved of by the ulema and was also considered a luxury, it was subjected, under the name “rüsûm-ı bid‘atiyye” (“dues on innovations”), to a tax twice the normal customs duty.

The state’s attitude also changed over time. According to Ahmet Yaşar, one reason for this was the economic value of coffee: the tax levied on it had become one of the treasury’s regular sources of revenue. Peçuylu İbrahim writes that grand viziers opened large coffeehouses as investments and earned considerable income from them.

The Coffeehouse Keepers’ Guild and the Janissaries

Yaşar draws attention to one more factor: the presence of Janissaries among the coffeehouse keepers changed the state’s approach to coffeehouses. The Coffee entry, too, regards the Janissary, âşık (minstrel) and semai (folk-song) coffeehouses that emerged over time as indicators of the stages Ottoman society went through. You can read about the structure of the corps in our article on who the Janissaries were and what they did.

The Social Role of the Ottoman Coffeehouse: Meddah, Karagöz and Conversation

The Ottoman coffeehouse was one of the main places of sociability in the city and over time became a kind of public space. According to Ahmet Yaşar, people of different social groups and levels of culture found a new cultural setting there. In a society where written culture was not widespread, the coffeehouse was one of the most important carriers of oral culture. From its earliest years it also served its regulars as a reading room.

According to Peçuylu İbrahim, pleasure-loving members of the educated class met in coffeehouses in groups of twenty or thirty. Some read books and writings on etiquette (âdâb-ı muâşeret), some played backgammon and chess, and others discussed poems they had just written. Reading books of religious content in an epic vein, such as the Muhammediyye, the Battalname and the Hamzaname, had become a tradition. Because of this educational role, coffeehouses were called “mekteb-i irfan” (“school of knowledge”) and “medresetü’l-ulemâ” (“madrasa of the learned”).

Illustrative scene of people drinking coffee and chatting around tables with chessboards in a coffeehouse hall decorated with calligraphy panels and bookshelves

The Meddah and Karagöz Stage

The coffeehouse was the most important venue for karagöz (shadow-puppet) shows and for performances by meddahs (storytellers); the âşıks (minstrels) also displayed their skills there. While entertaining the regulars, these performers also passed on to them a store of cultural knowledge. The number of meddahs and their role in society grew steadily from the 16th to the 18th century. Meddahs such as Kız Ahmed, whose fame spread to Europe in the 19th century, also took the stage in coffeehouses with the characters they portrayed.

Like coffee, the shadow play came from Egypt in the 16th century; it entered Ottoman lands through Mamluk artists. The name Karagöz, however, first appeared in the 17th century.

Who Supervised the Coffeehouses? The Qadi and the Muhtesib

Orders to close Ottoman coffeehouses were sent to the qadis (judges). The closure orders mentioned above had gone to the qadis of Eyüp, Galata and Istanbul, and the order of 1583 to the qadi of Istanbul. We discussed the qadi’s role in keeping order in the city in our article on what an Ottoman qadi did in court and in the city.

Alongside the qadi stood the muhtesib (market inspector). According to Ziya Kazıcı’s Hisbe (Hisba) entry, among the Ottomans the muhtesib was usually called the “ihtisap ağası” or the “ihtisap emini”. Wherever a qadi was appointed, a muhtesib was also present as his assistant; because Istanbul was so large, Galata, Üsküdar and Eyüp each had a muhtesib of their own. The ihtisap ağası dealt with the narh (officially fixed prices), saw that the tradesmen observed the rules, oversaw the opening of new shops and sought to maintain order in the city. The Hisbe entry does not mention coffeehouses specifically; these duties concern the general supervision of the tradesmen and of the city.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which Sultan Banned Coffee?

No single sultan banned coffee. Orders closing the coffeehouses were issued in the last years of Suleiman the Magnificent and afterwards; under Ahmed I, grand viziers also closed coffeehouses. The harshest coffee ban was Murad IV’s, in 1633; it was lifted in the early years of Mehmed IV’s reign.

When Was Coffee Banned in the Ottoman Empire?

According to al-Jaziri, news spread in Mecca in 1543 that the sultan had banned coffee in Istanbul. According to the mühimme records, coffeehouses were closed from 1559 onward in Homs, Aleppo, Damascus, Jerusalem, Egypt and Eyüp; the Coffee entry dates the closures in Istanbul and Galata to 1568. The harshest ban came in 1633.

Why Did Murad IV Close the Coffeehouses?

According to the Murad IV entry, when the Cibali fire of 1633 set off gossip in the coffeehouses, the sultan, urged on by Kadızade Mehmed Efendi, had the coffeehouses demolished on the pretext that a new fire might break out. Naima, for his part, says that the aim was to bring the ruffians and brigands to heel.

Was Coffee Haram in the Ottoman Empire?

According to the Coffee entry, the majority of the ulema considered coffee permissible. Some scholars objected because of the behavior in the coffeehouses; Kadızade Mehmed Efendi regarded coffee as bid‘a and haram. The şeyhülislam Bostanzade Mehmed Efendi, on the other hand, issued a fatwa in verse in favor of coffee in 1592.

Conclusion

In the 16th century Ottoman coffee was still a new drink from Yemen, yet it quickly settled at the center of city life. Because the coffeehouses were places of conversation, news and performance, they also became targets of the authorities. No single sultan imposed the bans; the harshest coffee ban came from Murad IV in 1633 and was lifted in the early years of Mehmed IV. In the end the state chose to tax coffee and to supervise the coffeehouse; Ottoman coffee culture went on spreading despite the bans.

Sources

Leave a Comment